Medicare Annual Enrollment is Happening Now! Everything You Need to Know

Read Our Guide

MobileHelp vs Bay Alarm Medical

70+ Years in Business
9+ Plan Options
Overall Rating:
4 of 5
Our Pick is Bay Alarm Medical
View Packages
24/7 Emergency Response
$21.95/mo Starting Price
Questions? Speak with a Bay Alarm Medical Specialist:
844-946-1712

Highest Rated Brands

MobileHelp might be right for you if:
mobilehelp
  • You and your spouse (or roommate) both need a medical alert system.
  • You want an easy-to-use touchscreen system.
  • You're interested in having telehealth services.
  • You own a large home.
Bay Alarm Medical might be right for you if:
Bay Alarm Medical
  • You're on a tight budget and only need monitoring for one person.
  • You want a caregiver tracking app to monitor your loved one.
  • You want a smartwatch system
  • You frequently travel or split your time between two homes.
Our editor Taylor Shuman's grandmother wearing Bay Alarm Medical's Mobile GPS button

Our editor Taylor Shuman’s grandmother wearing Bay Alarm Medical’s Mobile GPS button

If you're thinking about purchasing a medical alert system, you've likely realized just how many popular medical alert providers there are to choose from. To help you out on your search, we're comparing two of the industry's leading providers: MobileHelp and Bay Alarm Medical.

Overall, we highly recommend both providers, as they offer high-quality systems and reliable protection. Our comparison will simply help you determine the differences between both companies so you can pick the one that best aligns with your budget, safety, and health needs. For example, MobileHelp is best if you and a roommate or spouse both need monitoring, while Bay Alarm Medical is our pick if you're on a tight budget and want a simple system. Keep reading to learn more about how they stack up!

Our Editor Jeff Hoyt Testing Out MobileHelp

Our Editor Jeff Hoyt Testing Out MobileHelp

Side-by-Side Comparison of Bay Alarm Medical and MobileHelp

Features & Info MobileHelp Bay Alarm Medical
Connection types Landline and cellular (AT&T) Landline and cellular (AT&T)
In-home range Up to 1,400 feet Up to 1,000 feet
Battery life Mobile device: 24 hours

Base station: 30+-hour backup battery

Help button: 5+ years

Mobile devices: up to 4 days

Base station: 32-hour backup battery

Alert pendants: 5 years

Water-resistant equipment? Yes Yes
Redundant monitoring? Yes, two monitoring centers Yes, two monitoring centers
Two-way communication? Yes Yes
Language support? 240+ languages supported 170+ languages supported
Fall detection? Yes Yes
Price lock? Yes, with the purchase of MobileHelp Connect Premium Yes
Free trial? 30-day risk-free trial 30-day risk-free trial
Long-term contracts? No No

Who is MobileHelp?

MobileHelp is a medical alert company on a mission to “be someone's hero, every day.”1 In 2006, it became one of the first businesses to sell mobile medical alert systems. These devices use cell signals and GPS technology to keep seniors safe outside of the home. Today, MobileHelp employs over 200 people and brings in more than $20 million2 in yearly revenue.

The company is best known for its two-in-one systems that let roommates or spouses each have their own system while only paying one affordable monthly rate. Their latest MobileHelp Touch systems set this company apart, giving older adults additional health and wellness benefits like brain games and medication reminders.

Overview of MobileHelp's Services

MobileHelp Wall Button

MobileHelp Wall Button

MobileHelp specializes in at-home, on-the-go, and hybrid systems; there's an option for most everyone! Prices start at $19.95 per month, depending on the package you choose, making MobileHelp an affordable option. We'll take a quick look at each of the eight systems the company offers below.

MobileHelp Classic

This in-home system comes with a base unit and a wearable, waterproof help button for $19.95 per month. It has a 1,400-foot signal range and requires AT&T cell coverage, so it's best for seniors who live in an area with strong cell service.

MobileHelp Wired Home

This in-home system has a more modern-looking base unit that runs on a landline connection, so it's great for seniors in rural areas or who don't have reliable cellular coverage. It has a 1,300-foot signal range, perfect for larger homes, and a wearable help button, starting at $24.95 per month.

MobileHelp Touch Classic

The Touch Classic, a tablet with an eight-inch touchscreen, is a unique offering in the at-home category of medical alert systems. Starting at $54.95 per month, this system is perfect for older adults who are comfortable with technology, want a few extra features, and don't mind the higher monthly cost.

MobileHelp Solo

The Solo is an on-the-go cellular system with GPS technology and a 600-foot signal range from Mobile Device to a wearable button. There is no base station required; users carry a mobile unit and wear a help button on their wrist or around their neck, making it a reliable option for seniors who spend a lot of time outside the home. Prices start at $37.95 per month.

MobileHelp Micro

Weighing only 1.8 ounces, this mobile system is aptly named. The Micro includes two-way talk and GPS location detection. Unfortunately, it does not come with the option to add fall detection. Prices for this on-the-go system start as low as $29.95 per month with a one-time $79.99 equipment fee.

Mobile Duo

Designed for roommates or spouses who are always out and about, this system includes two MobileHelp Solo units for $44.95 per month.

MobileHelp Duo

The MobileHelp Duo bundles together the base station from MobileHelp Classic and the all-in-one MobileHelp Solo device. It's best for monitoring two users (one at home and one on the go), or for those who want a hybrid system. You'll pay $41.95 per month for this bundle

MobileHelp Touch Duo

This advanced hybrid system includes a high-tech touchscreen complete with brain games, medication reminders, and WiFi and Bluetooth capabilities. It also comes with a mobile unit and help button so you can monitor one or two users. Monthly rates start at $64.95 per month. We'd recommend this system for those who want high-tech features or a touchscreen system.

MobileHelp Monitoring Center & Customer Service

MobileHelp uses a third party to handle emergency calls and 24/7 professional monitoring. The company, called RapidResponse, has 25 years of experience, delivers top-notch service, and its operators undergo extensive training. RapidResponse is UL-certified and has redundant facilities, so you're always covered even if there's a power outage in one location.

Did You Know: The average medical alert company takes 15 to 45 seconds to respond. MobileHelp keeps things speedy with an average response time of 17 seconds.

Feel most comfortable speaking a language other than English? MobileHelp has you covered. This company supports 240+ languages, ensuring all seniors feel confident when calling for help. Bay Alarm Medical offers similar language support, so this is one area where both providers excel.

Who is Bay Alarm Medical?

Bay Alarm has 75 years of experience in the health technology industry, and the company founded Bay Alarm Medical, a subsidiary, in 2007. The company is currently headquartered in California and holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.3

Important Note: Bay Alarm Medical is well-known for developing the first in-car medical alert device. However, in May of 2021, a Bay Alarm Medical representative informed us that the system is no longer offered. The company hopes to relaunch the product with upgraded technology sometime in the future.

Bay Alarm Medical delivers some of the best prices in the business. Their in-home system starts at just $21.95 per month, and that price only jumps up by $8 per month if you prefer an all-in-one mobile system.

Overview of Bay Alarm Medical's Systems

Bay Alarm Medical - Wall Button

Bay Alarm Medical – Wall Button

Bay Alarm Medical sells three types of medical alert systems: In-Home, GPS Help Button, and an SOS Smartwatch. Just like MobileHelp, Bay Medical Alarm systems start at $21.95 per month. You can also bundle two of the company's systems together for a discounted rate.

In-Home

As the name suggests, this is an in-home system, featuring a 1,000-foot range and your choice of a landline or AT&T cellular connection. Prices begin at $21.95 per month for landline and $29.95 per month for cellular. Travel a lot? You can take the system with you and plug it in at any home.

GPS Help Button

Bay Alarm Medical's GPS Help Button is an all-in-one mobile system that comes with a water-resistant pendant equipped with a two-way speaker and GPS technology for at-home and on-the-go protection. Basic plans start at $29.95 per month, and you'll also pay a one-time $99 device fee. Caregiver tracking via a mobile app is also included to keep caregivers or family members in the loop.

SOS Smartwatch

This smartwatch is Bay Alarm Medical's latest and most high-tech system. It features an easy-to-navigate touchscreen, traditional watch face, step tracking, daily step goals, and an emergency help button. It's a solid option for active seniors who want a more discreet system that also offers health and fitness features. Prices start at $29.95 per month, and you'll also pay an upfront equipment fee of $179.

Bundles

Bay Alarm Medical gives you the option to bundle two of their systems together to save. With bundles starting at $51.95 per month, you can save up to around $100 on your first year of service compared to purchasing both systems separately.

Customer Service & Monitoring

Like MobileHelp, Bay Alarm Medical also offers language support for customers. Whether you're a native English, Spanish, or Mandarin speaker, you'll feel comfortable and confident talking with a customer service representative.

FYI: Bay Alarm Medical's average response time is 45 seconds. While this isn't as fast as MobileHelp, it's still within the industry standard of 15 to 45 seconds.

While its customer service team operates out of its California headquarters, Bay Alarm Medical's monitoring efforts come from a U.S.-based monitoring partner. The two redundant 24/7 monitoring call centers are in Ogden, Utah and Rexburg, Idaho. Both locations are UL-certified and CSAA Five Diamond Certified. In other words, they're top tier and always available should an emergency arise.

MobileHelp and Bay Alarm Medical Price Comparison

Now that you're familiar with both brands let's compare their monthly rates and other important pricing information.

Pricing 1nformation MobileHelp Bay Alarm Medical
Rates atarting at $19.95 per month $19.95 per month
At-home systems starting price range $19.95 to $54.95 per month $21.95 to $29.95 per month
On-the-go systems starting price range $29.95 to $37.95 per month $29.95 per month
Hybrid packages starting price range $41.95 to $64.95 per month $51.95 per month
Payment options Monthly, quarterly, semi-annual, and annual Monthly
Fall detection $10 per month $10 per month
Price lock Yes, with purchase of MobileHelp Connect Premium Yes
Equipment cost $79.99 for Micro system $99 fee for GPS button; $179 for SOS Smartwatch
Free Shipping Yes with some plans No
Activation and processing fees $49.95 – $99.95 for select systems with monthly payment plan No
Additional fees No No

Important Differences Between MobileHelp and Bay Alarm Medical

All-in-all, the two providers share a lot of similarities. Both have redundant 24/7 monitoring centers and landline and cellular options. So what are the significant differences between these two providers to consider?

MobileHelp On-The-Go Wrist Pendant

MobileHelp On-The-Go Wrist Pendant

1. Spousal Monitoring

1. Spousal Monitoring
MobileHelp offers two packages that make spousal or roommate monitoring more affordable—MobileHelp Duo and Mobile Duo. Bay Alarm Medical offers complimentary spousal monitoring with their in-home device (with the purchase of an additional button), and for an additional $20 per month (plus $99 equipment fee) spousal monitoring is available for a mobile system at a greatly reduced price. Still, MobileHelp offers the best prices overall and is our top pick.

2. The Cost of Mobile Monitoring

Both of Bay Alarm Medical's on-the-go systems, the GPS Help Button and SOS Smartwatch, start at just $29.95 per month. This price is very affordable compared to mobile systems from other companies, even when accounting for the one-time equipment fee. While the MobileHelp Micro costs a comparable $29.95 per month, the Solo comes in at a more costly $37.95 per month.

3. Product Lineup

Both providers offer in-home and on-the-go systems; however, MobileHelp offers eight different systems while Bay Alarm Medical's lineup is limited to three. However, Bay Alarm Medical still offers solid variety with their smartwatch and mobile offerings.

Pro Tip: Choosing a product bundle or hybrid system from either MobileHelp or Bay Alarm Medical can save you $100+ per year. These savings could free up your budget for any add-ons you're interested in, like a fall detection button or extra wall buttons.

4. Payment Options

MobileHelp offers one way to save money all year long—choosing a longer service plan. For most products, the longer the plan, the more you'll save. Selecting an annual plan over a monthly one could save you around $5 per month or up to $60 per year. Bay Alarm Medical only offers a monthly payment option, so that's one area where MobileHelp has a leg up on the competition.

MobileHelp vs. Bay Alarm Medical Add-Ons

If you're looking to add any extra features or equipment to your system, Bay Alarm Medical and MobileHelp both offer various add-ons. Below is a comparison.

Add-on MobileHelp Bay Alarm Medical
Fall detection $10 per month $10 per month
Lockbox Free for new customers ($29.95 value) $30 each
Vial of life N/A First free, then $8 each
Wall button $2.95 per month $35 per button
Telehealth aervices MDLIVE for $9.95 per month N/A
Jewelry pendant N/A Bella jewelry pendants for $25
Product protection MobileHelp Connect Premium for $5 per month Extended warranty for $3 to $5 per month

Is MobileHelp or Bay Alarm Medical Best For You?

If a particular system or company hasn't jumped out to you yet, there's no need to worry. You have many factors to consider, especially if this is your first time researching medical alert systems. Below, we've put together our recommendations based on the features and services offered by each company.

One last thing to remember as you decide which company to choose is this: MobileHelp and Bay Alarm Medical's mobile systems rely on AT&T's cellular network. If your loved one lives in an area with poor AT&T cellular service, their only options from both companies are the in-home landline units.

Our editor Taylor Shuman's grandma testing out Bay Alarm Medical's Mobile Help Button

Our editor Taylor Shuman’s grandma testing out Bay Alarm Medical’s Mobile Help Button

If you think your loved one needs a mobile system that uses a carrier other than AT&T, you'll need to look elsewhere. Thankfully, other medical alert companies partner with different mobile carriers. For example, Lively medical alert systems rely on Verizon.

The Bottom Line on Bay Alarm Medical vs. MobileHelp

Whether you're interested in Bay Alarm Medical's smartwatch system or MobileHelp's spouse monitoring, you will be in good hands with either provider. If you only need a barebones landline system or you're on a tight budget, Bay Alarm Medical is your most affordable choice. On the other hand, if you're looking for a touchscreen system or you and your partner both need monitoring, we recommend MobileHelp.

Overall, be sure to keep your loved one's needs, monthly budget for an alert system, and lifestyle in mind as you determine which system to purchase. For additional information, check out our MobileHelp review and our Bay Alarm Medical review.

Citations
  1. MobileHelp. (2020). Our Mission.

  2. Dun and Bradstreet. (2020). Mobilehelp, LLC.

  3. Better Business Bureau. (2020). Bay Alarm Medical.