The Best Medicare Supplement Insurance for Healthy Seniors

Our research team chose Humana as the top carrier of Medigap plans for healthy seniors thanks to their widespread availability, high enrollment discounts, and ample health and wellness perks.

Maureen Stanley
Maureen Stanley
Maureen Stanley
Who is Maureen Stanley?
Maureen joined SeniorLiving.org with more than 10 years of experience writing in health, lifestyle, and nutrition for premium brands like General Mills, Westinghouse, and Bristol Myers Squibb. Her passion for empowering older adults is evident in coverage of topics like… Learn More
Writer & Editor
Our Methodology

Our experts researched the industry’s leading Medigap plans and narrowed down the list to our top picks for healthy seniors and other Medicare beneficiaries.

75
Hours of Research
12
Carriers Considered
3
Experts Consulted
5
Carriers Selected

How We Researched the Best Medigap Plans for Healthy Adults

Here’s how we evaluated each Medigap carrier:

  1. Our team visited each carrier’s website to see what they offered. We gave priority to Medigap carriers that made it easy to see which plans were available in our area and provided instant quotes. We also looked for plans that specifically mention health and wellness benefits that go beyond what’s offered with Original Medicare.
  2. We read through each plan carefully (including the fine print) to weed out plans that don’t offer as much coverage for adults who live an active or healthy lifestyle.
  3. We spoke to representatives from each carrier on the phone to ask questions about pricing and coverage, particularly for carriers that did not offer as much information on their websites. That also gave us useful information about the quality of each carrier’s customer support team.
  4. We compared notes and narrowed down our list to the top Medigap carriers and plans for healthy Medicare beneficiaries.

How We Chose the Best Medigap Plans for Healthy Adults

Here are the most important factors we considered for Medicare beneficiaries shopping for a Medigap plan that suits their health and lifestyle:

  • Medigap plans offered: There are 10 Medigap plans on the market, four of which are no longer offered to new Medicare beneficiaries. Insurance carriers also vary in the number and type of plans they offer. We looked for carriers that offer more plans, giving consumers more options to choose a plan within their price range.
  • Health and wellness benefits: We wanted to make sure the carriers we chose would help healthy adults stay healthy. Nearly every carrier on our list has options for adults to get discounts or coverage for wellness products, including gym memberships, healthy diet plans, massages, OTC and prescription medications, and more.
  • Plan premiums and deductibles: Medigap plans are designed to reduce out-of-pocket Medicare costs such as deductibles, coinsurance, and copays. If a Medigap plan has a deductible and a high premium, however, beneficiaries may not save as much on out-of-pocket costs. We looked for carriers that offer plans with low premiums and low or no deductibles.
  • Cost transparency: We appreciate transparency when it comes to monthly premiums and deductibles, as well as coverage for Medicare deductibles, copays, and coinsurance. We primarily focused on carriers with websites that offered fast quotes and price-comparison tools.
  • Plan availability: Not all Medigap plans are available in every state, and some carriers don’t operate in all 50 states. We looked for carriers that offer a wide network. Keep in mind that even if a carrier offers Medigap in your state, they may not offer plans in your ZIP code.
  • Customer service: Since Medigap is offered only through private insurance companies, it’s important to consider their customer service. We contacted each carrier and spoke with representatives to ensure that they offer helpful and friendly customer service. We also read through reviews of each carrier to see what real customers had to say.
  • Carrier reputation: We considered the carrier’s reputation as a dependable insurance company. We researched their ratings from trusted organizations such as the Better Business Bureau, AM Best, and S&P Global.

Why Trust Us?

Our experts have spent hundreds of hours reviewing and evaluating Medicare Advantage and Medigap plans for eligible beneficiaries. We also consulted with healthy Medicare beneficiaries and households to learn about their personal experiences with different carriers and gain better insights into their advantages and disadvantages.

SeniorLiving.org is supported by commissions from providers listed on our site. Read our Editorial Guidelines

Written By:
Maureen Stanley
Writer & Editor
Read About Our Panel of Experts
Maureen joined SeniorLiving.org with more than 10 years of experience writing in health, lifestyle, and nutrition for premium brands like General Mills, Westinghouse, and Bristol Myers Squibb. Her passion for empowering older adults is evident in coverage of topics like… Learn More About Maureen Stanley